Search found 666 matches

by Lego
2020-07-12 22:18
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

Means absolute zilch There's something about your recent posts that feels aggressive, Lego. I don't know why but I suggest you drop it. Quote from the forum rules: "The spirit of this forum is one of curiosity, respect and friendly, productive participation. We are exploring a fascinating field whe...
by Lego
2020-07-12 22:15
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)

As I’ve described previously, an uncontrolled test of this kind is likely to produce a split decision. Statistically, where's the proof? It sounds suspect mathematically. https://youtu.be/zrpUDuUtxPM Enjoyed it thanks ,even though the tracks in my clips weren't in mono ,though probably the the Geor...
by Lego
2020-07-12 21:28
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

That's hilarious Corrina 😂 If you're not already involved,then I think you should seriously consider going into politics,as you very well know it's never too late.! Not sure I understand your post but kind of hope that you misunderstood mine. If not clear, I was commenting on clip comparions in gen...
by Lego
2020-07-12 21:22
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

It appears to me there's confusion around the use and value of comparative clips. This is how I see it: • The purpose of sharing clips is to increase one's understanding of a certain difference. Both the person recording&posting the clips and the listeners can gain insights in the process. • The di...
by Lego
2020-07-12 16:18
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

To me there is one interesting investigation that should be done, namely: Comparing the results of a closed vote between ”agreed experts” in tunedem with the results of other voters. The controversial part may be how to nominate the agreed tunedem group but this being Fredrik’s forum I suggest he n...
by Lego
2020-07-12 15:49
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS (update)

I would like to see the results of the individual tests. Like X number of votes for A and X number of votes for B. Is it possible you could share this information with us? Had a recount EMM and it's now 13 for Hakai and 12 for Generic PC . 6 voted for K .......Gen PC 5 voted for L ..........Hakai 4...
by Lego
2020-07-12 14:35
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS (update)

El Mero Mero wrote:
2020-07-12 12:20
I would like to see the results of the individual tests. Like X number of votes for A and X number of votes for B. Is it possible you could share this information with us?
Re reading what you just said I'm not sure what you mean
by Lego
2020-07-11 20:46
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

To be fair I only asked what do you prefer,maybe 'and why' should be added .To go from 95% in favour of one clip to very close to 50/50 in a secret ballot says a lot for me. The clips here have come a long way from this product A and this is product B which one do you prefer,which was happening a l...
by Lego
2020-07-11 13:39
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

I wasn't saying you were evangelising Beck ,what I was meaning was that if someone were to say they prefer a particular clip because of a b and c etc it's hard not to influence someone listening afterwards
by Lego
2020-07-11 12:48
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

The Hak seemed to instill more of an emotional reaction in me without being able to say why and in the GPC the musicians seemed to be playing more together as if they were more aware of each others playing .A backing singer in one particular track made the track sound more like a duet . Now we are ...
by Lego
2020-07-11 06:06
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

I didn't find the difference that great,and unlike you I haven't come to a conclusion whether one is significantly better than the other So the reason for the poll is that you had trouble deciding which is better? How would you describe the differences between the two? Is the PC one that you find p...
by Lego
2020-07-11 05:53
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS

That's interesting that you only wanted to listen to the first set of clips Frederik.£55 is not cheap I've been busy building products on order and making comparisons at my lab for about 12 hours every day for the last month, Lego. Apologies that your multiple polls didn't rise to the top of my lis...
by Lego
2020-07-11 00:45
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

Then something is seriously wrong with your HAKAI, Lego. It sounded terrible IMO. What parts were used and which software? Possibly Frederik ,I used the parts you suggested except the SATA cable which I still have in the box .It's the original software you recommended. Is that a comparative judgmen...
by Lego
2020-07-11 00:29
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS

I disagree. The upside is that there's less bias. The downside is that there are no discussions and reasoning. And I think that is more important than finding out what the unbiased majority thinks. what were you hearing that was so bad with the Hakai I usually listen to clips once and get an immedi...
by Lego
2020-07-10 22:28
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS

Secret ballots are the way forward. They offer herd immunity with no downsides. I disagree. The upside is that there's less bias. The downside is that there are no discussions and reasoning. And I think that is more important than finding out what the unbiased majority thinks. what were you hearing...
by Lego
2020-07-10 21:38
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

Then something is seriously wrong with your HAKAI, Lego. It sounded terrible IMO. What parts were used and which software? Possibly Frederik ,I used the parts you suggested except the SATA cable which I still have in the box .It's the original software you recommended. Is that a comparative judgmen...
by Lego
2020-07-10 20:25
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC
Replies: 49
Views: 902

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC

W is Hakai
by Lego
2020-07-10 20:13
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS

beck wrote:
2020-07-10 18:57
You have put W on both devices.......

and where is K.....?

S versus W, L versus K, A versus B and C versus D are the comparisons that have been posted.
Hahahaha ,I just saw that Beck thanks.Good to see you're paying attention
by Lego
2020-07-10 18:56
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS

Hakai was L W A and D Generic PC was S W B and C 11 voted for GPC 13 voted for Hakai Only one person voted for same streamer and that was FPM who voted for Hakai on every occasion. Thanks again for helping me out on this,it was very illuminating . Well, something is wrong with W! :-) Don't start Be...
by Lego
2020-07-10 17:47
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)
Replies: 34
Views: 415

Hakai Vs £55 PC SB RESULTS RECOUNT !!! (UPDATE)

Hakai was L W A and D

Generic PC was S K B and C

12 voted for GPC

13 voted for Hakai

Only one person voted for same streamer and that was FPM who voted for Hakai on every occasion.

Thanks again for helping me out on this,it was very illuminating .
by Lego
2020-07-09 18:47
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC final clips (SECRET BALLOT)
Replies: 7
Views: 200

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC final clips (SECRET BALLOT)

FairPlayMotty wrote:
2020-07-09 17:41
I'd use the best one as the player.

My two servers (one Gigabyte-based and one Intel-based) are indistinguishable from each other but both sound vastly superior to my Netgear ReadyNAS.
Thanks FPM
by Lego
2020-07-09 16:47
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC final clips (SECRET BALLOT)
Replies: 7
Views: 200

Hakai Vs £55 PC final clips (SECRET BALLOT)

This time I'm doing an AB CD comparison 😂 The first voting on the secret ballot was too close to call ,so hoping this final one will help clarify These will be the final clips and thanks to everyone for helping me decide which device I should use for my Nas and player .Though not sure if I should us...
by Lego
2020-07-07 21:30
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC (Secret Ballot)
Replies: 10
Views: 411

Re: Hakai Vs £55 PC (Secret Ballot)

lejonklou wrote:
2020-07-07 20:50
How does this correlate to your other post with the same question?
I've always wondered how much people are influenced by other votes as the last post was overwhelmingly one sided .
by Lego
2020-07-07 16:28
Forum: HAKAI
Topic: Hakai Vs £55 PC (Secret Ballot)
Replies: 10
Views: 411

Hakai Vs £55 PC (Secret Ballot)

Which do you prefer of these 2 new clips

Could you PM me your vote if it's not too much trouble ,thanks .


L) https://vimeo.com/436120005


K)https://vimeo.com/436116819