Search found 146 matches

by lindsayt
2023-11-05 13:01
Forum: HiFi
Topic: More on source first and other priorities
Replies: 72
Views: 187696

Re: More on source first and other priorities

Spannko wrote: 2023-11-03 18:47 On the topic of great sounding speakers, how’s your diy speakers project coming along lindsayt? 😊
Sometimes, other things in life take a higher priority than hi-fi.
by lindsayt
2023-11-03 18:41
Forum: HiFi
Topic: More on source first and other priorities
Replies: 72
Views: 187696

Re: More on source first and other priorities

Yeah, source first was best. Here's a hypothetical system for you since I haven't done a real world comparison. 1. Klimax LP12 > Sagatun Monos > Tundra Monos > Inexpressive speakers that don't let the music through very well 2. Selekt LP12 > Boazu > Majik 109s I think I'd pick system 2. So, the sam...
by lindsayt
2023-11-03 16:28
Forum: HiFi
Topic: More on source first and other priorities
Replies: 72
Views: 187696

Re: More on source first and other priorities

So you compared a vinyl system against a CD / DVD system? That's more extreme or differently extreme to what I had in mind. I was thinking of comparing 2 vinyl, or 2 CD or 2 streaming systems. And of having 2 good but not quite equal sources. And 2 very different pairs of speakers, with one pair as ...
by lindsayt
2023-11-03 13:43
Forum: HiFi
Topic: More on source first and other priorities
Replies: 72
Views: 187696

Re: More on source first and other priorities

How extreme a practical demonstration does anyone want to put on? For example System A The most tuneful sounding source available for a given recording format, a decent sounding amplifier, 2014 B&W CM1 speakers (untuneful budget speakers) The second most tuneful sounding source available for that fo...
by lindsayt
2023-09-30 07:47
Forum: HiFi
Topic: Is there a “best” test track?
Replies: 18
Views: 21493

Re: Is there a “best” test track?

If I used Steely Dan as a test track, I'd be too distracted by how grated I was by Fagen's vocals to be of any use when it came to evaluating the equipment. Too bad they didn't have Freddie Mercury as their lead singer. Have you got any recommendations? What do you usually use to evaluate a new com...
by lindsayt
2023-09-28 16:01
Forum: HiFi
Topic: Is there a “best” test track?
Replies: 18
Views: 21493

Re: Is there a “best” test track?

If I used Steely Dan as a test track, I'd be too distracted by how grated I was by Fagen's vocals to be of any use when it came to evaluating the equipment. Too bad they didn't have Freddie Mercury as their lead singer.
by lindsayt
2023-09-23 16:37
Forum: HiFi
Topic: Is there a “best” test track?
Replies: 18
Views: 21493

Re: Is there a “best” test track?

The Roches The Troubles is the sort of track that a good hi-fi system can get very close to making it sound like it's being performed live in your listening room.

Especially if you could get a hold of the master tape or a master tape copy.
by lindsayt
2023-09-20 08:39
Forum: HiFi
Topic: Is there a “best” test track?
Replies: 18
Views: 21493

Re: Is there a “best” test track?

Harman International. The fount of all knowledge on hi-fi :)

Although I suppose, given the aquisitive nature of their business, in a few years time they might be the fount of all hi-fi products.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harman_International
by lindsayt
2023-09-19 09:03
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

Thanks Rutger. That makes your findings doubly interesting! Internal damping is something I’ve really struggled to get to work well. However, I think my methodology may not be very good so it’s not been possible to come to any definitive conclusions. Tuning the enclosure volume without filling is r...
by lindsayt
2023-09-09 13:52
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

If only 18mm void-free birch plywood was cheap! Or even available (in the UK)! One advantage of birch plywood for DIY projects is that, in my opinion you don't need to veneer it to look acceptable. I think that birch plywood has a natural beauty to it. The joint most musical sounding speakers I've h...
by lindsayt
2023-07-31 08:09
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

https://www.lejonklou.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=14 " To maximise the quality of music reproduction, the order of importance is (from most to least): The performance of the artist, the recording, the record/CD/file, the source component that replays the record/CD/file, the preamplifier, the powe...
by lindsayt
2023-07-28 09:27
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

The one without compression would always sound better. I don’t agree. I have a very high respect for the producers of an album. I also consider the final version of an album to be THE work of art for the audience to enjoy, applaud or criticise. Therefore I also consider the practice of making diffe...
by lindsayt
2023-07-27 08:33
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

There are those in mixing and production who know what they’re doing and those that do not. The only way I have been able to tell them apart is by listening. I haven’t found any numbers or specific techniques to be a short cut to the answer. I fully agree. I am just curious how the musical result w...
by lindsayt
2023-07-26 20:20
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

I would enjoy listening to the 9.7 more than the 3.4. Both versions have ridiculous amounts of clipping. The contrast between the quieter bits and the louder bits on the 9.7 is significantly greater on the 9.7. Resulting in that sounding less bad. A better sounding version would have no clipping and...
by lindsayt
2023-07-25 10:00
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

Personally, I’ve never been able to correlate musical enjoyment with DR rating. Some high DR recordings are enjoyable and some less so. Here’s a low DR album I quite enjoy https://open.spotify.com/album/16J9NCaxxRc2QW999f5V9H?si=gNqpWq70TROeEGbeCke_Kw Here’s an album not listed in the DR database, ...
by lindsayt
2023-07-24 05:48
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

There are loads of examples of albums that have been remastered with more compression being used than earlier versions. The more compressed versions have always sounded worse (with appropriate adjustment to the volume knob when comparing each version). It's impossible for me to say if any of my albu...
by lindsayt
2023-07-23 22:46
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

matthias wrote: 2023-07-23 13:58
lindsayt wrote: 2023-07-23 09:45 dynamic compression
Sorry for OT but interesting that even ECM Records use it. I am wondering how their records would sound without it.
Better.
by lindsayt
2023-07-23 09:45
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

Although we have gotten a little off topic here, there is a video file posted above I wanted to address so I'll carry us a little further off... I find it the video posted by Spannko very interesting for a couple of reasons. One is that the second track, a streamed one is a pretty "audiophile" type...
by lindsayt
2023-07-21 11:13
Forum: HiFi
Topic: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...
Replies: 69
Views: 130304

Re: LP12 50: If Jony Ive made record players...

Here’s 360’s set up by Linn. https://youtu.be/EgvVhwQI0gc I was there in room, I found it inferior to a good set-up with 3677s at a fraction of that price. It's the high efficiency large woofered thing vs the low efficiency medium-sized woofered thing. Just goes to show, an extremely high retail pr...
by lindsayt
2023-04-30 15:02
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

Thx brother Matss! Letivin is on route to me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEZkz4Li-0M 1st few mins deals with bias. Mr. Sean Olive is compelling. We're getting to a spin-off topic of a spin-off topic. The issue with blind listening tests is that they put the listener in a state of stress. Becau...
by lindsayt
2023-04-29 11:07
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

1 aspect of this forum drew me in the way my JBL308P engage me. This discussion of speaker musicality baffles me in 1 sense. Lots of y'all love the 308P, others do not. Lots of y'all love the Briks, others do not. Lots of y'all love the Kans, others do not. Some of y'all love other Linn speakers, o...
by lindsayt
2023-04-29 10:53
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

If a source and amplifier sound bad with one pair of speakers whilst sounding good with another, is that the fault of the source and amplification, or a fault with the speakers? I’m not sure tbh. Personally, I’d like to think that a genuinely good loudspeaker should sound good with all sources, but...
by lindsayt
2023-04-28 03:09
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

I've heard Kans with a variety of sources and amplification over the years, starting with LP12, Ittok, Asak, Naim 32.5, 250. If a source and amplifier sound bad with one pair of speakers whilst sounding good with another, is that the fault of the source and amplification, or a fault with the speaker...
by lindsayt
2023-04-27 11:59
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

I love Kans which have tiny drive units. I've thoroughly enjoyed 242s many times as well and they are the sort of speaker you dislike. I've yet to hear any make of speaker I prefer to Linn but I'm open to that, with or without 18" woofers. I hate Kans! They are too transistor radioey for me. I can ...
by lindsayt
2023-04-25 21:02
Forum: HiFi
Topic: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?
Replies: 154
Views: 908717

Re: What Makes a Loudspeaker Musical?

I think this became a more theoretical discussion which is good for sharing some experiences but is maybe the not so perfect approach in a forum where we speak about musicality … especially when non of us has heard the 360‘s live. I might take the chance to hear them at the High End in Munich to ha...